Choosing the Right 3PL Partner: A Comprehensive Checklist

Katherine Wroth • October 24, 2024

According to a 2022 Third-Party Logistics study of over 300 respondents, 73% of shippers (3PL users) reported that partnering with a 3PL has enhanced their customers' experiences while introducing innovative ways to improve logistics effectiveness. Even more impressive, 86% of shippers agreed that using a 3PL has led to greater cost-efficiency in their logistics operations.


Over the past decade, the logistics industry has undergone significant shifts, with a surge in 3PL providers aiming to capitalize on the global market’s expansion. But buyers, beware—not all 3PLs are created equal.


With countless options, how do you make the right choice? Here's a comprehensive checklist to help you navigate the selection process and find the best 3PL partner for your business.


1. Industry Experience

One of the first things to consider when choosing a 3PL partner is their experience in your industry. Look for a provider that understands logistics and has expertise in your specific market. For example, we specialize in e-commerce, retail  and omnichannel fulfillment at Barrett. This deep knowledge allows us to anticipate and address industry-specific challenges.


Checklist:

  • Does the 3PL have experience in your industry?
  • Can they provide case studies or references from similar clients?
  • Do they understand the seasonal peaks and trends specific to your business?



2. Scalability

Your business will evolve, and your 3PL partner should be able to grow with you. Flexibility and scalability are essential, whether you’re expanding into new markets or scaling up during peak seasons.


Checklist:

  • Can the 3PL accommodate your growth?
  • Do they offer flexible solutions that can adapt to your changing needs?
  • Are their facilities and technology systems equipped to handle future expansions?


Barrett Partnership Testimonial:


"The Barrett team does a great job of being flexible and responsive to all our logistics needs. Ken’s Foods exists in a dynamic manufacturing environment, and we continually challenge Barrett with last-minute changes to our just-in-time world, supporting our packaging operation and managing outbound distribution. Our multi-year relationship started small, and each year we do more with Barrett as they have become a reliable and trusted asset in helping us manage the tremendous growth we experience annually."
— Jim Bourne, Sr. Director @
Ken’s Foods



3. Technology and Innovation

Technology is crucial to supply chain success. A 3PL partner should provide cutting-edge solutions for real-time tracking, inventory management and data analytics to ensure efficiency and transparency across the supply chain. Our advanced systems offer real-time tracking, giving customers complete visibility into their shipments from origin to destination. This transparency allows for proactive decision-making and swift problem resolution, ensuring potential disruptions are handled before they impact your business.


Checklist:

  • Does the 3PL offer advanced technology for inventory and order management?
  • Can you track your shipments and inventory in real-time?
  • Do they provide data-driven insights to help optimize your operations?



4. Geographical Reach

Where are your customers located? Does your 3PL have the network to meet those demands? Whether your business operates regionally, nationally, or internationally, your 3PL provider needs a robust and strategically placed network to support your growth. Barrett, for example, offers a comprehensive footprint across key logistics hubs in the United States, with a network of over 26+ locations in cities such as Boston, Los Angeles, Memphis and Dallas.


Checklist:

  • Does the 3PL have strategically located facilities that align with your customer base?
  • Do they offer global solutions if your business operates internationally?
  • How quickly can they deliver to your key markets?



5. Customization, Personalization and Flexibility

Every business is unique, and your 3PL partner should offer value-added services tailored to your specific needs. From personalized packaging to custom fulfillment services, flexibility in operations is key to ensuring that your brand identity is maintained throughout the customer experience.


Our capabilities extend to services like personalized kitting, custom engraving, embroidery and branded packaging—ensuring that your products make an impact from the moment they reach the consumer. With Barrett’s personalized solutions, as a 3PL provider, we become an extension of your brand, helping you deliver products and memorable customer experiences that reinforce your market presence.


Checklist:

  • Can the 3PL tailor its services to match your business model?
  • Do they offer value-added services like kitting, assembly, or custom packaging?
  • Are they willing to adapt to your brand’s specific requirements?



6. Customer Service and Communication

Communication is the cornerstone of a successful 3PL partnership, and at Barrett, we pride ourselves on our commitment to one-call resolution. Our teams are trained to be proactive and empowered to make decisions, so when you reach out to Barrett, you're not just getting a representative—you’re engaging with a logistics expert who understands your business and can take immediate action. Whether you’re looking for real-time updates on your shipment, need to address an unexpected challenge, or require a quick adjustment to your fulfillment process, Barrett’s focus on one-call resolution means that your concerns are prioritized and handled swiftly.


Checklist:

  • Is there a dedicated point of contact for your account?
  • How responsive is the 3PL in addressing issues or concerns?
  • Do they offer proactive communication during disruptions or delays?



7. Cost Transparency

While cost shouldn’t be the only factor in your decision, working with a 3PL that provides transparent pricing is crucial. Hidden fees or unexpected charges can negatively impact your bottom line.


Checklist:

  • Is their pricing structure straightforward and easy to understand?
  • Do they offer a breakdown of all potential fees?
  • Can they help you find cost-saving opportunities without sacrificing service quality?



8. Reputation and Stability

Finally, choosing a 3PL with a solid reputation and a proven track record is essential. Barrett has been in business since 1941, giving us over 80 years of experience in the supply chain industry. Barrett’s long history isn’t just about experience—it’s about trust. Over the decades, we’ve built strong relationships with our clients by consistently delivering results, innovating our services and staying ahead of industry trends. Our ability to evolve while maintaining the highest service standards has allowed us to navigate industry challenges and shifts, proving that we’re not just here for the short term but committed to long-term success for our partners.


Checklist:

  • How long has the 3PL been in business?
  • Do they have positive reviews and testimonials from other clients?
  • Are they financially stable and capable of supporting your growth?



Conclusion

Choosing the right 3PL partner is more than just ticking boxes—it’s about finding a provider who can act as a true extension of your business. At Barrett Distribution Centers, we pride ourselves on being a partner who not only delivers operational excellence but also shares your vision for success.


Looking to explore how Barrett’s solutions can help your business scale and simplify your supply chain? Contact us today to chat with one of our experts.

Recent Blog Posts

By Katherine Wroth February 20, 2025
At Barrett Distribution, continuous improvement is at the core of everything we do. Our commitment to operational excellence and employee engagement drives us to find innovative ways to enhance efficiency, quality, and teamwork. One of our key strategies for fostering this culture is our Quarterly Mini Games—focused initiatives encouraging teams across our facilities to collaborate, set measurable goals, and implement process enhancements that drive business impact and client satisfaction. Celebrating Success: Q4 Mini Games The Q4 Mini Game presentations highlighted Barrett’s dedication to improving quality and efficiency. These initiatives targeted reducing incident creation, improving LP accuracy, and strengthening collaboration. Teams reported significant incident reductions, cost savings, and increased client satisfaction. Employee engagement and open communication were key drivers of success, reinforcing the power of teamwork and innovation. Mini Game themes at Barrett:  - Quality is Just Around the Corner - Race to Receive - Kicking it into High Gear Quality Assurance and Incident Tracking Daniel Ryder, Assistant Operations Manager, led the team’s quality assurance efforts by tracking pallet quality, monitoring shipping errors, and categorizing incidents for research. Their goals included: Reducing incident creation Improving LP accuracy Implementing a new pick auditing process Increasing leadership presence on the dock These efforts resulted in a 31% reduction in weekly incidents and a 9.3% reduction in cases impacted. The improvements had a significant financial impact, proving the effectiveness of their auditing process and revised cycle count program. Inbound Process Improvements and Cost Savings For the Race to Receive Mini Game. Joe Reynolds, Assistant Ops Manager, discussed the implementation of a new one-step receiving process in the inbound department for a popular apparel brand. By implementing a new one-step receiving process, the team: Increased dock-to-stock efficiency from 75% to 90% Reduced inbound headcount from three employees to one Achieved $100,000+ in annual cost savings Cleared 40 inbound containers with 100% accuracy in January and February These results showcase the team’s operational excellence and commitment to continuous improvement. Mini Game Success in Inbound Processes Walter Gonzalez, Operations Manager, and Nick Morello, Warehouse Lead, demonstrated the impact of an initiative focused on inbound and put-away processes for a leading apparel brand. The team: Increased put-away units per hour from 205 to 252 Achieved 53.2 UPH against a 44.8 baseline Expedited in-transit selling for customers Realized $19,081 in Q4 labor savings, with projected annual savings of $38,000 Walter emphasized that these achievements were driven by associate engagement and ownership, with team members actively tracking daily results. Collaboration and Communication: The Keys to Success Open communication and employee input were essential to these improvements. The team stressed the importance of: Encouraging small ideas that lead to significant efficiency gains Maintaining a proactive approach during challenges like volume decreases and late shipments Fostering a positive work environment to sustain morale and productivity Voting and Celebration After three strong Mini Game presentations, teams participated in the voting, naming one of our New Jersey facilities (NJ3) as the Q4 winner. Driving Continuous Improvement for Better Partnerships At Barrett, continuous improvement is a mindset that fuels our success and strengthens our partnerships. Through initiatives like our Quarterly Mini Games, we empower our teams to optimize processes, reduce costs, and enhance quality while fostering a culture of collaboration and innovation. These efforts benefit our internal operations and directly impact our clients by improving efficiency, accuracy and overall service excellence. Contact Barrett today to see how our expertise can help optimize your supply chain and drive long-term success.
By Katherine Wroth February 19, 2025
 When you think of e-commerce fulfillment, you probably picture warehouses buzzing with activity, sophisticated inventory systems and fast shipping. However, one significant aspect that doesn’t always get the spotlight is the relationship between fulfillment and marketing. Though these departments may seem separate, they are closely linked and can significantly influence one another. This blog delves into why this connection matters and how e-commerce businesses can use it. The Overlap Between Marketing and Fulfillment At first glance, marketing and fulfillment serve distinct roles; marketing focuses on attracting customers and building a brand, while fulfillment ensures that products are delivered efficiently. However, these functions work together in more ways than one, and when aligned strategically, they can enhance the customer experience and improve business performance. Turning Fulfillment into a Marketing Advantage New Epsilon research indicates that 80% of consumers are likelier to purchase when brands offer personalized experiences. One of the most direct ways fulfillments support marketing is by turning the delivery experience into an extension of the brand. This concept, often called marketing fulfillment, allows businesses to use their shipping and packaging process to reinforce brand identity and WOW customers. For example, personalized packaging , handwritten thank-you notes, and small surprise gifts can all create a memorable unboxing experience. These small touches enhance customer satisfaction and encourage repeat purchases and word-of-mouth recommendations. A unique unboxing experience can set a brand apart and turn a routine delivery into a moment customers want to share, especially on social media, where user-generated content can serve as powerful organic marketing. The Role of Branded Packaging Packaging is more than just a protective layer for products; it’s a branding opportunity. Thoughtfully designed packaging can communicate a company’s personality, values and commitment to quality. Whether eco-friendly materials, eye-catching designs, or a compelling message printed inside the box, branded packaging extends marketing reach beyond the digital space. Customers who receive a premium package that aligns with the brand’s image are more likely to develop a strong connection with the business. Additionally, packaging can serve as a form of passive advertising. A well-designed box attracts attention during delivery and may even spark curiosity among potential new customers who see it. Driving Additional Sales Through Fulfillment Fulfillment isn’t just about getting products into customers’ hands—it’s also an opportunity to drive further sales. Businesses can strategically include promotional inserts, discount codes, or product recommendations inside packages, encouraging customers to make additional purchases. Another way to capitalize on fulfillment for marketing purposes is through post-purchase emails. Sending personalized recommendations or exclusive offers shortly after delivery can keep customers engaged and increase the chances of repeat business. Customer Experience and Brand Reputation One of the most important connections between fulfillment and marketing is how it impacts customer satisfaction. Fast, reliable shipping has become a baseline expectation, and any delays or mistakes in fulfillment can lead to frustration and negative reviews. On the other hand, when orders arrive on time, in perfect condition, and with a thoughtful presentation, customers are more likely to leave positive reviews and recommend the brand to others. A positive fulfillment process can turn one-time buyers into loyal customers and brand advocates. Leveraging a 3PL for Fulfillment and Marketing Success Many e-commerce brands partner with third-party logistics (3PL) providers to streamline their fulfillment operations. However, not all 3PLs offer the same level of service, and choosing the right partner can greatly impact marketing efforts. Access to Marketing Partnerships Some 3PLs offer opportunities for co-marketing beyond basic warehousing and shipping. At Barrett, we spotlight our partners and look for ways to provide additional marketing support, social media advertising, or collaborations—all of which can help brands expand their reach and engage with their audience more effectively. By partnering with a 3PL that integrates marketing opportunities, e-commerce brands can extend their reach, enhance customer engagement and maximize the full potential of their logistics partnership. Data-Driven Marketing Strategies A tech-savvy 3PL can provide valuable data insights that help businesses refine their marketing strategies. By analyzing order trends, customer preferences, and delivery performance, brands can make informed decisions about everything from inventory management to promotional campaigns. For example, understanding peak purchasing periods can help businesses time their marketing campaigns for maximum impact, while insights into regional demand can inform targeted advertising strategies. Enhancing the Customer Journey A 3PL that prioritizes the customer experience can directly support marketing goals by ensuring smooth post-purchase interactions. Features like real-time order tracking, hassle-free returns, and flexible delivery options contribute to overall customer satisfaction, strengthening brand loyalty. When customers have a seamless experience from the moment they place an order to the moment they receive it, they are more likely to return and recommend the brand to others. Marketing and Fulfillment: A Powerful Duo When fulfillment and marketing work in sync, they transform from business functions into powerful catalysts for customer satisfaction and revenue expansion. The opportunities to integrate fulfillment with marketing are endless, from crafting memorable unboxing experiences to leveraging data for strategic campaigns. Partnering with a 3PL that understands and supports this connection can further enhance these efforts, helping e-commerce brands scale while maintaining a strong, customer-focused approach. By recognizing fulfillment as a key marketing asset, businesses can build deeper customer relationships, increase brand loyalty and drive long-term growth. Take Your Fulfillment and Your Brand to the Next Level Ready to transform your fulfillment into a marketing powerhouse? Contact us today to learn how Barrett can help and receive a complimentary supply chain consultation.
By Katherine Wroth February 18, 2025
What happens when your business takes off overnight? E-commerce brands don’t fail because they can’t sell. They fail because they can’t fulfill. If you’re an e-Comm. brand, you probably started your business with a system that met your needs at the time. However, success can quickly become challenging without a flexible fulfillment strategy, leading to higher costs, bottlenecks and frustrated customers. In this post, we’ll discuss how scalable fulfillment impacts your business and how to find the right 3PL partner to keep operations running smoothly. What Is Scalable E-commerce Fulfillment? Scalable fulfillment refers to a logistics provider’s ability to adjust operations to accommodate fluctuating order volumes. This includes adapting labor resources, leveraging automation, optimizing warehouse management and fine-tuning order processing. If any part of this system fails to scale effectively, inefficiencies arise—delays, errors and unhappy customers. While early-stage businesses often prioritize affordability and convenience when selecting a fulfillment solution, building scalability into your strategy early on is key to long-term success. Why Scalability Matters in Fulfillment 1. Self-Fulfillment Can Only Take You So Far Most e-commerce businesses start by fulfilling orders themselves. This makes sense—it’s cost-effective and gives merchants complete control over packaging and shipping. In the early days, you only needed was storage space, shipping materials and a label printer. But as sales grow, the limitations of self-fulfillment become clear. More orders mean more inventory, packaging and labor. Maintaining order tracking, SKU management and shipping deadlines becomes a full-time job. Without the right infrastructure, delays mount, errors increase and customers look elsewhere. 2. Maintaining Quality as You Scale You can inspect every package with a low order volume, ensuring accuracy and crafting a great unboxing experience. But as demand grows, maintaining that same attention to detail becomes difficult. Many 3PLs struggle to replicate the same personalized experience, which can impact customer loyalty. Scaling fulfillment ensures that your customers continue to receive the quality they expect—even as order volumes grow. 3. Managing Seasonal Peaks and Slowdowns Many e-commerce businesses experience fluctuating demand. Whether it’s holiday shopping surges or slow post-season periods, fulfillment operations must be agile enough to scale up or down.  Without a flexible system, brands may overinvest in infrastructure they don’t always need or face fulfillment slowdowns when they need to ramp up. A scalable fulfillment partner helps you adjust resources, preventing costly inefficiencies. What to Look for in a Scalable Fulfillment Partner If your business is growing, choosing the right 3PL partner is critical. Here’s what to prioritize: 1. A Nationwide Fulfillment Network A single fulfillment center can quickly become overwhelmed. Instead, look for a partner with multiple strategically located warehouses . This allows you to: ✅ Speed up delivery times by distributing inventory closer to customers ✅ Prevent bottlenecks by shifting fulfillment to different locations ✅ Ensure seamless fulfillment even during unexpected surges 2. Automated Fulfillment Solutions Automation reduces reliance on seasonal labor, improves accuracy and speeds up order processing. With ongoing labor shortages, 3PLs integrating automation—such as robotic picking, AI-driven inventory management and automated sorting—offer a significant advantage. 3. Technology That Grows with You Your fulfillment partner’s tech stack should handle your business’s growth—not just for today but for years to come. Ask potential providers: ✔ Can their systems manage a rapid increase in order volume? ✔ Do they integrate with your e-commerce platform and order management system? ✔ Do they offer real-time inventory tracking and predictive analytics? 4. Scalable Value-Added Services Branded packaging , kitting and special inserts can enhance the customer experience—but can your fulfillment provider handle these extras as you scale? Ensure they can maintain the same level of personalization and quality even as order volumes rise. 5. Reliable Customer Support Fast fulfillment is only part of the equation. A scalable provider should also help you maintain strong customer service, offering: 🔹 Real-time order tracking to reduce customer inquiries 🔹 Streamlined returns processing 🔹 Dedicated support teams to handle peak-season demand The Bottom Line: Future-Proof Your Fulfillment Strategy Scaling your fulfillment operations isn’t just about keeping up with growth—it’s about setting your business up for long-term success. The right fulfillment partner will help you stay agile, efficient and prepared for whatever comes next. If you’re looking for a fulfillment provider who can support your business through every growth stage, Barrett is here to help. Let’s discuss how we can build a scalable, seamless fulfillment strategy for your brand. Contact us today for a complimentary supply chain consultation to meet with one of our Barrett experts.
More Posts
Share by: